Conference: Earth’s Canvas: Exploring Geology in Creativity, The Geological Society

Introduction

The Heavy Water Col­lec­tive is an art col­lec­tive com­pris­ing Vic­to­ria Lucas, Maud Haya-Baviera and Joan­na Whit­tle. Our long term artis­tic research project, estab­lished in 2020, responds cre­ative­ly to traces of his­to­ry, sit­u­at­ing archive-based research in a con­tem­po­rary con­text through the pro­duc­tion of art­works. Heavy Water takes its name from D2O, a form of water used for the sta­bil­i­sa­tion of volatile mat­ter. The mate­ri­al­i­ty of Heavy Water is mys­ti­cal; per­me­at­ing organ­ic bod­ies, calm­ing vio­lent cre­ations, ground­ing and giv­ing weight to some­thing flu­id and intan­gi­ble. It is rep­re­sen­ta­tive of our process­es of inves­ti­ga­tion and meth­ods of mak­ing, devel­oped in response to shared sub­ject matter.

Our col­lab­o­ra­tion is dis­tinct­ly cura­to­r­i­al. Art­works devel­oped in par­al­lel by three artists are brought togeth­er in con­fig­u­ra­tions that gen­er­ate new insight that is rela­tion­al and respon­sive to the archives and col­lec­tions inves­ti­gat­ed. Our recent exhi­bi­tion at Ground­Work Gallery, King Lynn, which ran over sum­mer 2024, is a suc­cess­ful illus­tra­tion of this work­ing method. Respond­ing to the col­lec­tions held at the Sedg­wick Muse­um of Earth Sci­ences in Cam­bridge, we have each devel­oped threads of research that, through sus­tained dia­logue, weave a net­work of mean­ing between the result­ing art­works exhibited.

Heavy Water, GroundWork Gallery Installation, 2024

This exhi­bi­tion re-imag­ines our con­nec­tion to mate­r­i­al land­scapes that have been explored, exploit­ed, or are under threat. Imag­in­ing what might be, while reflect­ing on and revi­tal­is­ing traces of the past, is a vital process of eval­u­a­tive revi­sion­ing that we feel is cur­rent­ly lack­ing in the con­text of late cap­i­tal­ism and in the midst of cli­mat­ic break­down. We believe that there is intrin­sic val­ue in imag­i­na­tive reflec­tion, because it enables one to cre­ative­ly reveal and explore what is at stake. Imag­in­ing and re-mythol­o­gis­ing post-indus­tri­al and pre-indus­tri­al land­scapes through arte­facts in this way pro­vides a gen­tle empha­sis that con­cep­tu­al­ly re-entan­gles humans to the land through its mate­r­i­al qual­i­ties. Mys­tery and myth are buried back into the land through artis­tic prac­tice here, in a way that re-con­cep­tu­alis­es them in a time of envi­ron­men­tal crisis.

Untitled (Coal)

artwork

1 Jun 2024

Victoria Lucas

William Smith’s 1815 Geo­log­i­cal Map A Delin­eation of the Stra­ta of Eng­land and Wales’, sits at the heart of the exhi­bi­tion. A repro­duc­tion of the orig­i­nal map on dis­play at the Sedg­wick Muse­um of Earth Sci­ence in Cam­bridge, this appro­pri­at­ed ver­sion presents us with a series of delin­eat­ed absences. Coal­fields, which Smith orig­i­nal­ly high­light­ed in undu­la­tions of grey, have been phys­i­cal­ly removed — extract­ed — and replaced by a black sub­stance laced with coal dust. Through this act the coal is cen­tralised as my sub­ject, and the repro­duc­tion of the map becomes a con­duit for the mate­ri­al­i­ty it represents. 

For me, Smith’s map sym­bol­is­es a cul­tur­al shift towards per­ceiv­ing nature as an indus­tri­al prod­uct to be exploit­ed. Not only is this a stun­ning­ly beau­ti­ful illus­tra­tion of the rich and var­ied geol­o­gy of Britain; it is also a blue­print that in-part enabled the lan­guage of geol­o­gy as a sci­ence to infil­trate the mate­ri­al­i­ty of the stra­ta beneath our feet, and with it unrav­el the cul­tur­al and folk­loric mean­ings that under­pinned a place-based sense of intrigue and belong­ing across the land­scapes of Britain. Devel­oped dur­ing the indus­tri­al rev­o­lu­tion, when mytholo­gies and the poten­tial­i­ty of mag­ic gave way to the hard sci­ence of indus­try, this map is a charged object that, in the con­text of this exhi­bi­tion, con­t­a­m­i­nates and con­tex­tu­alis­es the oth­er works on display. 

Portals

artwork

1 Jun 2024

My sculp­tur­al instal­la­tion enti­tled Por­tals (2024) is made out of the same earth­ly mate­r­i­al that forms the map’s infill. Sym­bol­ic of the man­made forms found in mine shafts, these del­i­cate, skin-like sculp­tures are digi­tised rep­re­sen­ta­tions of the bro­ken earth made man­i­fest, as 3D mod­els of under­ground sys­tems are trans­lat­ed back into phys­i­cal objects using fos­silised, organ­ic mat­ter from prehistory. 

The mate­r­i­al res­o­nance of these works form a phys­i­cal mark­er that brings the coal­fields of York­shire — and the thou­sands of dis­used shafts and out­crops that punc­ture this land­scape — to the fore through the slow-time his­to­ry of the earth itself. These works rep­re­sent the absences below ground in a way that reveals the myr­i­ad of con­nect­ed mate­r­i­al, social, cul­tur­al and eco­nom­ic his­to­ries sit­u­at­ed deep beneath our feet. 

Also made man­i­fest in coal is the ouroboros snake, which I re-con­tex­tu­alise with spe­cif­ic ref­er­ence to indus­tri­al min­ing prac­tices that have shaped the post-indus­tri­al land­scapes of my home-coun­ty of York­shire. With­in the con­tem­po­rary con­text of cli­mate emer­gen­cies and mass extinc­tions, Self Destruc­tive Acts II (2024) repo­si­tions this ancient sym­bol of rebirth and uni­ty as a prophet­ic warn­ing, as the human race moves seem­ing­ly towards their own destruction.

Indeed, snakes fea­ture heav­i­ly in the work, as atem­po­ral crea­tures that slith­er through the under­worlds of many cul­tures, mytholo­gies, reli­gions and folk­lore. The stony heads of ser­pent stones are play­ful­ly returned inSnake­stones (Coal) I and II for exam­ple, and fea­ture in the dis­play case sit­u­at­ed in the cen­tre space exhi­bi­tion.

Self-Destructive Acts II

artwork

2 Jun 2024

Snakestone (Coal) II

artwork

2 Jun 2024

Snakestone (Coal) I

artwork

2 Jun 2024

In my video work enti­tled Chan­nelling (To Dwell Under­neath the Ground) the snake, as the estab­lished guardian of the mines, is revered through an entan­gled and mate­ri­al­ly embed­ded rein­ter­pre­ta­tion of Greek Mythol­o­gy, Eng­lish Folk­lore and the post-indus­tri­al land­scapes that I have encoun­tered through research under­tak­en at the Nation­al Coal Min­ing Muse­um in addi­tion to the Sedgwick. 

Channelling (To Dwell Underneath the Ground)

artwork

2 Jul 2024

Channelling (To Dwell Underneath the Ground)

artwork

2 Jul 2024

Channelling (To Dwell Underneath the Ground)

artwork

2 Jul 2024

Maud Haya-Baviera

In my work, the rep­re­sen­ta­tion of mate­r­i­al absence is expressed through a renounce­ment of all claims to glob­al com­pre­hen­sion”, as Didi-Huber­man writes in The Eye of His­to­ry1. My col­lages, whether pho­to­graph­ic or sculp­tur­al, are atem­po­ral and not geo­log­i­cal­ly or geo­graph­i­cal­ly accu­rate, yet they attempt to organ­ise and arrange what can nev­er be ful­ly grasped and under­stood. This is most evi­denced in my col­lage Volatile Com­pounds #2 (2024) in which I cre­ate a fic­ti­tious demar­ca­tion, a map-like zone of inter­est that refers to Lucas’ appro­pri­a­tion of Smith’s Geo­log­i­cal Map. In this work, I imag­ine poten­tial future min­ing zones, while also play­ful­ly evok­ing the chalk mark­ing left by the police around a dead body. Through amal­ga­mat­ed objects and images, I com­pose new his­tor­i­cal knowl­edge that merges myths, alche­my and sci­en­tif­ic evi­dence, where past, present and imag­ined futures converge. 

My ini­tial inter­est when encoun­ter­ing the archives of the Sedg­wick Muse­um lay upon fas­ci­nat­ing tales of dis­cov­ery. The thirst for knowl­edge exhib­it­ed by sci­en­tists such as Dar­win or Anning was enthralling. Yet, through­out my work, I also dis­play an ambiva­lence towards the his­to­ri­og­ra­phy of human dis­cov­er­ies, and the entan­gle­ment between explo­ration and exploita­tion, which is too rarely acknowledged. 

The recur­rence of the hand in the body of work pre­sent­ed at Ground­Work gallery is, for me, a way to nar­rate the human impli­ca­tion in extrac­tive prac­tices. The sym­bol­ic nature of the rep­re­sen­ta­tion of the hand alludes to and explores the realms of labour, dis­cov­er­ies, and equiv­o­cal acts of gen­eros­i­ty. In Volatile Com­pounds (Giv­ing or Tak­ing) (2024) — which is a work made of kaoli­n­ite porce­lain, a min­er­al sub­stance mined from the earth — a hand holds a dia­mond in a ges­ture that can be both under­stood as a gift or as a demon­stra­tion of wealth. The repli­ca of the crys­tal can also be per­ceived as a pen­du­lum, a spir­i­tu­al tool used to answer com­plex ques­tions, or to direct its own­er towards rich findings.

In Volatile Com­pounds (The Stain) (2024), a wax derived from the petro­le­um indus­try is used to cre­ate a hand that is seem­ing­ly dis­eased, and whose peel­ing skin has tak­en the col­oration of an oil spill; a taint that also match­es the radioac­tive land­scapes of my pho­to­graph­ic collages. 

The nefar­i­ous title of the work Volatile Com­pounds (The Con­spir­a­cy) (2024) invites us to imag­ine a con­ver­sa­tion between two bronze fin­gers which, like the hands, are anthro­poid sym­bols. Bronze is used in numer­ous pieces in my work. This alloy has been cho­sen because it pri­mar­i­ly con­sists of cop­per, whose indus­tri­al his­to­ry I came across on my first vis­it to the Sedg­wick Muse­um. The transocean­ic phe­nom­e­non of cop­per exploita­tion began in the ear­li­er part of the 19th Cen­tu­ry in the Unit­ed King­dom, when smelt­ing tech­nol­o­gy in the coun­try start­ed to use coal-fired fur­naces, increas­ing the capac­i­ty and need to extract cop­per worldwide.Today, cop­per min­ing is still leav­ing its destruc­tive marks on both the envi­ron­ment and the health of its work­ers and neigh­bour­ing min­ing pop­u­la­tions, and its neg­a­tive colo­nial lega­cy is unde­ni­able. The works in bronze then invite us, as Dar­win did when he vis­it­ed Chilean cop­per mines, to mar­vel at human inge­nu­ity and to dream of the mag­i­cal pow­ers bestowed upon cop­per, but they also warn of the lure of cap­i­tal­ist enrich­ment and its exploita­tive nature. 

In Volatile Com­pounds (The Inver­sion) (2024), I ref­er­ence Sea­henge, a pre­his­toric mon­u­ment that includes a mag­nif­i­cent tree stump buried upside down on the Nor­folk shores. The pur­pose of this bronze age instal­la­tion has nev­er been deter­mined, but its benev­o­lent aura and its asso­ci­a­tion with death and decay are con­tra­dic­tions that appeal to me. 

The porce­lain and brass work Volatile Com­pounds (In Con­stant Motion) (2024) also refers to archival objects found in Nor­folk, in this instance, a Nebra Sky Disc, a bronze age plate used as both an astro­nom­i­cal instru­ment and an object of worship. 

With my ceram­ic work, I evoke ruined civil­i­sa­tions and fos­silised sea crea­tures, which I com­bine with ocean­ic and inter­plan­e­tary land­scapes. The work pro­pos­es a new nar­ra­tive akin to a beguil­ing myth. The pieces are all of pock­et sizes, as if reli­gious icons of an unknown belief system. 

The seduc­tive nature of my images and objects is posi­tioned as a lure to gen­er­ate dis­cus­sion, while putting to the fore­front his­tor­i­cal facts often ignored as well as prob­lem­at­ic remem­brances of the past. For me, the jux­ta­po­si­tion of cho­sen forms such as the hand and fin­gers, and mate­r­i­al such as wax, cop­per and Kaoli­n­ite is a crit­i­cal poet­ic ges­ture, a method which opens con­ver­sa­tions and makes it pos­si­ble to attempt to take a posi­tion towards the real by mod­i­fy­ing and rear­rang­ing the respec­tive posi­tions of dis­cours­es, objects and images.

Joanna Whittle

My body of work at Ground­Work Gallery, includ­ing this oil paint­ing enti­tled Trans­fig­u­ra­tion (Illu­mi­na­tion), was devel­oped in response to the Sval­bard Expe­di­tion col­lec­tion, held at the Sedg­wick Muse­um Col­lec­tions Research Cen­tre. The works take the con­cept and struc­ture of pil­grim­age, start­ing with the Sedg­wick club excur­sions to bucol­ic British land­scapes in the late 1800s and ear­ly 20th cen­tu­ry and end­ing in the Sval­bard research expe­di­tions from the 1930s to the 1960s. The work pro­duced pulls these threads into a sin­gle jour­ney, which ends at Sval­bard. My visu­al ref­er­ences to this Nordic expe­di­tion pull land­scapes through time towards the Arctic’s slow and omi­nous trans­fig­u­ra­tion. Shel­ters glow against unin­hab­it­able climes, as ice melt desta­bilis­es and under­mines these makeshift struc­tures. As the Arc­tic ice caps melt, anoth­er poten­tial land­scape for exploita­tion is revealed. 

In approach­ing archives, I begin with a con­fir­ma­tion bias, look­ing for arte­facts and pro­tag­o­nists that I can insert into this pre-exist­ing nar­ra­tive; that of the human on earth and their pas­sage through a his­to­ry punc­tu­at­ed by war and envi­ron­men­tal destruc­tion. In this body of research I most close­ly focus on the Sedg­wick Club’s last expe­di­tion in Dol­w­eryn in 1914, before the dis­rup­tion of WW1, and I jux­ta­pose it with the Sval­bard Archive. War fea­tures strong­ly in my work, due to its dis­rup­tion to both humans and to the land­scapes it takes place in. But there is also a sense of tem­po­ral dis­rup­tion due to the trau­ma of war, and in this nar­ra­tive I pull fig­ures from these ear­ly expe­di­tions through these fis­sures that war opens up, drag­ging them again through the sec­ond world war to the post war expe­di­tions to Svalbard. 

In my draw­ings, I com­bine sources and lay­ers them into new nar­ra­tives. Here a rock for­ma­tion from a pho­to­graph from the Doly­w­ern expe­di­tion in 1914, hov­ers above a draw­ing of an imag­ined row of arc­tic peaks derived from a small draw­ing of fos­silised teeth in the Sedg­wick muse­um by Agosti­no Scil­la ( 1639 – 1700), one of the ear­li­est writ­ers on fos­sils. My prac­tice also includes ceram­ics, and my small paper clay bur­nished box­es rep­re­sent portable taber­na­cles in this pil­grim­age. These were inspired by a small leather case, which appeared repeat­ed­ly in Bri­an Harland’s films where it emerges, is con­cealed and re-emerges from the mouths of tents, and through rep­e­ti­tion becomes ritualistic. 

In the dis­play case and around the wall, ceram­ics and draw­ings punc­tu­ate this jour­ney and inter­act with Lucas’ Por­tals, as if these por­tals are punc­tur­ing time and allow­ing these sites and pil­grims to slip through. The pil­grims were devel­oped from the ear­ly Sedg­wick Club expe­di­tions, where pho­tog­ra­phers swathed in their cam­era hoods appear as appari­tions and shapeshifters on Welsh hill­sides. I imag­ine them on their slow and steady jour­ney towards the ice, pass­ing anoth­er sta­tion of the pil­grim­age — Sanc­to­ri­um’ — which emerges from a Doly­w­ern outcrop. 

The final stage of the jour­ney pulls the pil­grims through a gate­way of glac­i­ers (from the Sval­bard Archive), seem­ing­ly nes­tled in snow but baked by the fires of the kiln, brown and brit­tle and dry. 

My paint­ings of tents rep­re­sent the end of the jour­ney, the sup­posed trans­fig­u­ra­tion where the pil­grims reach their high­est point of enlight­en­ment. They are again tak­en from Bri­an Harland’s Sval­bard expe­di­tion films. In the films, silk tents bil­low in icy winds, and in the paint­ings they sit in flood­ed ground illu­mi­nat­ed and translu­cent. They are shrines to the land­scape, they are shrines to lost glac­i­ers and to the ice which pools around them. Fore­sight was not tak­en and illu­mi­na­tion comes too late. 

Conclusion

In this exhi­bi­tion, Heavy Water treads the lim­i­nal space between sci­ence and myth, in the con­text of an envi­ron­men­tal cri­sis, to unearth new ways of con­nect­ing with a nat­ur­al world that is in a state of unprece­dent­ed tur­bu­lence. The min­ing activ­i­ty that fuelled the indus­tri­al rev­o­lu­tion is intrin­si­cal­ly linked to ris­ing glob­al tem­per­a­tures, and we as a col­lec­tive draw sub­tle con­nec­tions between min­er­al extrac­tion and melt­ing ice, through the cura­to­r­i­al deci­sions made.

The exhi­bi­tion intro­duces the pos­si­ble futures of min­ing, high­light­ing pat­terns of human and non-human exploita­tion through works that care­ful­ly hold ten­sions. Draw­ing on the past, this exhi­bi­tion relo­cates mean­ing in a way that is mate­ri­al­ly, social­ly and cul­tur­al­ly sig­nif­i­cant, as meth­ods of agi­ta­tion are sought in a world that is col­laps­ing under­neath the weight of con­tin­ued uneth­i­cal and dam­ag­ing actions.

The Collective’s engage­ment with archival mate­r­i­al and col­lec­tions, and the sub­se­quent works and con­ver­sa­tions that arise through the cura­tion, rep­re­sent an ongo­ing evo­lu­tion of these arte­facts reach­ing through time to the present. The trans­la­tion, appro­pri­a­tion and trans­for­ma­tion of the mate­r­i­al through cre­ative process speak of the sig­nif­i­cance of hun­dreds of years worth of research, passed from hand to hand to hand to reach those who still unearth it today. This is the posi­tion of Heavy Water; we per­form expe­di­tions through archives, unearthing the truths and mis­con­cep­tions that are inter­spersed through the stra­ta of the collection.